I don't know that I have any exceptionally perceptive insight on the tragedy in Connecticut and where God is in all of this, but I keep hearing other Christian voices espousing things that make me cringe and that, I believe, are unbiblical, their claims to the contrary notwithstanding. More and more people in our society seem to have nothing but disdain for the Christian Faith, and maybe it's just because they are only hearing one perspective. I thought I would add a different voice.
Regarding prayer in schools... There
always will be prayer in school! You cannot take prayer out of school. In addition to the legality in most schools of student-led prayer gatherings,
anyone can pray...
any time... in
any place. No one can stop that. In terms of public, teacher-led prayers in classrooms, all I can say, I guess, is that I'm an increasingly-old man, and there were never prayers offered in my classrooms when I was growing up. So, I'm not sure where such prayers were offered and where they weren't in the 1950's, but they didn't happen where I was, and it seems to me that my faith in Jesus developed fairly well despite no "prayer in school."
And more, regarding prayer in schools... A very close friend and colleague of mine several years ago told me about his pastoral work in a church-related school in Utah. That community had organized, daily prayers in the public schools. His sons were in that school system. His comment to me about that? "I have a different experience about prayer in schools from having my sons being led in prayer by Mormon teachers. Don't tell me that students aren't negatively affected by public prayers led by someone of a different faith tradition than your own! And don't tell me that such prayers are 'voluntary!' Students are mercilessly shunned if they don't fall in line and pray 'appropriately' during that daily time in the classroom!"
Regarding some people's claims that we've "taken God out of schools"... I don't have words strong enough (or appropriate enough!) adequately to express my feelings about this. Folks...
we can't control God! We can't "take God out of schools," because we don't have that much power... we don't have
any power over God! Psalm 139 reminds us that there is no place where God is not already there...
including schools, even though we no longer can have teacher-led prayers there!
Finally, regarding God and tragedies... As in the paragraph above, I don't have words strong enough to express my reaction to "Christians" who imply that
any tragedy is somehow the result of our faithlessness, and of God's subsequent action/judgment on us for that! Are tragedies sometimes the result of our actions or inactions? Undeniably so. Are
all tragedies the result of God's judgment? Absolutely not! That's not only cruel to suggest, and a slam on God's character and nature, but it's not biblical! Jesus was asked who sinned that caused a certain man they met to be born blind. Jesus said that sin had nothing to do with it. Jesus was asked why God's judgment was meted out when a tower fell in a nearby town, killing many people. Jesus said that God wasn't behind the fall of that tower and the resultant deaths of those people. Sin has consequences, and sometimes tragic things result. But, since we live in a broken and fallen world, sometimes bad stuff just happens, with no discernible cause and effect... other than perhaps shoddy workmanship... or mental illness... or easily-available ammunition that is manufactured with the
intent of killing people. The question about why bad things happen is certainly at least as old as the biblical book of Job... and Job never got any answers to his questions about "why." So I don't think we will find such answers either.
And whatever answers we develop, they certainly ought not be simplistic... or without compassion... or presumptive... or unbiblical.